Need Advice for family situation

Ask a Therapist Seeking Help
1

My sister Sue is age 48 and has not worked for over 6 months since completing her GCE O Levels. She rarely leaves her room, except to get meals from the kitchen. She surfs the internet all day long. Unfortunately, my mother is very accommodating of Sue’s every want, fearing her temper and always giving in to avoid conflict. Due to her level of education, Sue could not find a job that was comfortable enough for her. She eventually told our mom that she no longer wanted to work, and mom accepted this.

Meanwhile, I’ve been providing a monthly allowance to our parents, but I feel that part of this support is enabling Sue’s current lifestyle. My mother is protective of Sue and is not willing to encourage her to find a job or pursue something meaningful. My father, though aware of the situation, is also hesitant to confront either Sue or my mom about it.

I feel troubled knowing that my monthly allowance may be unintentionally supporting Sue’s current lifestyle.

Given these family dynamics, how should we approach this situation?

2

Hi @user1525

Thank you for courageously bringing up this issue in an effort to understand and resolve it. I agree that navigating the situation with your sister Sue and the family dynamics surrounding her behaviour can be challenging. You are feeling uneasy and frustrated with the current arrangement which is fully understandable.

It seems that your mother’s accommodating nature and fear of conflict may be enabling Sue’s current lifestyle. Enabling behaviors can include your mom giving in to demands, providing financial support without setting boundaries, or avoiding confrontation with Sue about unhealthy behaviours. I think with you providing financial support, it may be inadvertently reinforcing Sue’s lack of motivation to seek employment or engage in meaningful activities.

Do consider the following steps to address the situation:

-Open Communication: Consider having an open and honest conversation with your parents about your concerns regarding Sue’s behavior. Express how you feel about enabling her lifestyle and the potential long-term consequences for her well-being. Use “I” statements to communicate your feelings without sounding accusatory (e.g., “I feel worried about Sue’s future when I see her not engaging in any work or activities”).

-Set Boundaries: It may be necessary to establish clear boundaries regarding your financial support. You might decide to reduce the allowance or specify that it should only be used for essential expenses. This can encourage your family to reassess their approach to Sue’s situation.

-Encourage Professional Help: Suggest that Sue speaks with a counsellor or therapist who can help her explore her feelings about work and personal goals. Professional guidance can provide her with tools to cope with her situation and motivate her toward positive change.

-Support Your Mother: Since your mother may struggle with the idea of confronting Sue, offer support in helping her understand the importance of encouraging Sue to seek independence and fulfillment. You could suggest family counselling as a way for everyone to express their feelings and concerns in a safe environment.

-Explore Alternatives Together: If Sue is resistant to traditional employment, consider discussing alternative options such as part time work as a start. Engage Sue to consider volunteering, taking courses, or pursuing hobbies that could lead to job opportunities or personal growth.

To focus on family well-being:

-Address Family Roles: Acknowledge that these dynamics affect everyone in the family, not just Sue. Discuss how each member’s role contributes to the overall situation and explore healthier ways of interacting.

-Promote Open Dialogue: Encourage regular family discussions where everyone can share their thoughts and feelings without fear of conflict. This can help build understanding and support among family members.

-Seek External Support: If needed, look into family therapy and dialogue on enabling behaviours and codependency. These resources can provide valuable insights and strategies for improving family dynamics.

By approaching this situation thoughtfully and collaboratively, you can foster a healthier environment that encourages Sue toward independence while also addressing the concerns of everyone involved. :heartpulse:

3

Dear Caring Bee,

Thank you very much for your insightful input; it’s deeply appreciated. My apologies for the delayed response—things have been quite hectic on the home and work fronts recently.

I completely agree with your point about the enabling behavior surrounding Sue, largely driven by my mother’s accommodating nature and fear of conflict, as well as my financial support to my parents. I’ve already taken steps to set boundaries on the monthly allowance, ensuring it’s used only for essential expenses, such as groceries.

Regarding Encouraging Professional Help, could you share more about the specific tools that might be beneficial for Sue in coping with her situation and finding motivation toward positive change? A better understanding of this could help me encourage her to consider counseling.

On the point of Supporting My Mother, I agree that she needs support to understand and address the importance of Sue’s independence. Could you suggest where we can go for family counseling services?

As for Promoting Open Dialogue, this is challenging as Sue currently avoids any interaction with family members, even when I visit my mom. She remains in her room and hasn’t engaged with me directly in over eight years. For now, I feel that helping my mother understand the situation might be a critical first step.

Additionally, you noted the importance of Seeking External Support to address enabling behaviors and codependency within the family. Could you recommend resources that focus on these areas?

Once again, sincere thanks for your guidance.

Warm regards,
User 1525

4

Hi @user1525

Thank you for updates. Glad you have set boundaries with your mother on the use of the financial support you provide.

It may be good to initiate time with Sue when you next visit your mother. Engage her, invite Sue to join your parents and you for outings, meals or activities. It would be awkward initially but despite the discomfort or push back, do continue taking tiny steps in this direction.

With a stronger relationship established over time, Sue may be more open to your sharing of resources. It will take time, though so will need to be patient. Small steps to get started.

For family counselling services and resources, I suggest you can explore with the nearest family services centre. Your mother and you could go first and take a step by step approach towards eventually including Sue.

It’s laudable that you are seeking a change for the better and making efforts towards improvements♥️. Keep going, one small step at a time.